Betty Phillips was promoted into the
job of her dreams three months ago. As a nurse manager in a large teaching
hospital in New York, she was now in a position to apply her hard earned MBA
and fully use her natural leadership skills. By every measure, she should be on
cloud nine. She is a respected member of the leadership team, the hours are
more regular, her salary is very good and the responsibilities fit her
strengths perfectly. Right now, however, it's 3:00 AM, and she is sitting in
her living room with the TV for company, and she is miserable. Betty would give
anything to be back in her old job. She longs to be just "one of the staff."
She is truly puzzled. and is at a loss to explain her feelings.
What do you think is going on here? Is Betty in over her head?
Did she make a mistake in taking this job? Is she somehow neurotic or is what
she is experiencing a normal part of any major life transition?
In reflecting on Betty's situation, I pulled down off the shelf,
my well-worn copy of William Bridges classic, "Transitions: Making Sense of
Life's Changes" to more fully understand Betty's struggle. William Bridges
refers to Betty's feelings as symptomatic of what he calls the Neutral
Zone. She no longer fits in her old job and has yet to be integrated into
the nurse manager's position. In many respects, Betty is grieving for a time in
her life that is forever gone. She is experiencing the best kept secret of all
new leaders, "transitioning into new positions can often be isolating and
lonely!"
Those of us who coach leaders are not immune to the isolation
associated with a major career change. As a young man, I left a company where I
had earned high credibility and enjoyed many friends, to move to a training
manager's job in a new city. My first assignment took me to Palm Desert,
California to conduct a two-day workshop for the top sales managers in the
company. The event was a success and I left on an emotional high. I flew back
to Boston, dropped my bags in my apartment, and believe it or not, got in my
car and drove one hour back to my old neighborhood to seek out my friends and
colleagues. The loneliness and isolation of the new job, despite my recent
success, was overwhelming. Fortunately for me, I eventually worked through this
difficult period with the help and guidance of the people close to me.
So how do leaders navigate this difficult phenomenon that
frequently accompanies career change?
-
Anticipate and Accept -
The first step in dealing with the Neutral Zone, is to understand that this
experience is fairly common. Psychologists tell us that our identities at work
are defined by a number of factors including: relationships, status, routines
and titles. Is it any wonder that we miss our old way of life when we move on?
The intensity of these feelings often catches us off guard. It is important to
understand that these situations are normal and temporary. In "Transitions,"
William Bridges suggests that we cope with the Neutral Zone by finding a
regular time and place to be alone. As tempting as it may be to stay ultra busy
and ignore the Neutral Zone, such behavior may result in missing the
many valuable insights this period can offer. Meditation, quiet time or jogging
can be ideal ways to make the most of this challenging time, even if only for a
half-hour each day. It just might be that Betty Phillips, in her own way, is
doing that during her late night reflections.
-
Act As If - The
challenges of isolation and loneliness are especially difficult for first-time
managers and leaders. The pull to "remain one of the gang" is strong and must
be dealt with directly. At these times, it's important that we 'act as if" we
feel confident even when we don't. In a recent interview, the division
president of a medical devices company offered the following advice on this
subject, New managers need to recognize that the organization, especially if
they grew up in that organization, expect them to be different. Intent and
impact are magnified in this case. Even if you want the organization to see you
as the same person, they demand that you fill the role of President, VP, etc.
So even when you are struggling with your new role "act as if" you are
fully comfortable with your responsibilities or to use my favorite quote, "fake
it until you make it." Betty Phillips may be having a have a difficult time
with her transition, but when the bell rings and she joins the hustle and
bustle at work, she can benefit from " acting as if" as she puts one foot in
front of the other.
-
Focus on Your Mission -
A senior executive recently shared with me how he learned to manage the
period of isolation that took place three months into his new job. This
individual was completely surprised by his "illogical" desire to return to his
old job and its familiar surroundings. He turned to a trusted friend for advice
and was asked the following question, "What was it that initially attracted you
to your current position?" "What were your hopes and dreams for the new
situation?" The executive quickly described, in some detail, his mission for
the new job and as he did, his misgivings and contradictory feelings began to
dissipate. What is your compelling mission for your job and how does it keep
you going in difficult times?
Every major life change including weddings, births and new jobs
brings with it conflicting feelings. Keep in mind that in career changes, this
Neutral Zone is highly predictable and normal. I hope that whenever you
encounter this challenging phenomenon, you apply these suggestions and become
even more successful in your career.
M. J. Campbell Associates offers a coaching process, "The
Successful Transition," to assist newly appointed managers and executives in
successfully transitioning to a new position. Please check our
Successful Transition page for details.